Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: ? Of The Day - October 6, 2005


2011 Super Bowl Champions!

Status: Offline
Posts: 29950
Date:
? Of The Day - October 6, 2005


Ok, less of a question, more of a topic.

There's a website out there called http://www.whosarat.com

It is a database of undercover agents and informants.

Is this something you think is a good idea?

Does this fall under "free speech"?

How long before someone winds up dead because of this website?

Other thoughts?

__________________


Chairwoman Of The Board

Status: Offline
Posts: 665
Date:

Can't anything be kept a secret these days?  The internet: a blessing and a curse all at the same time.


 


I realize that's not a good opinion, but that's what I'm thinking right now.



__________________
Thank you for being a friend!


2011 Super Bowl Champions!

Status: Offline
Posts: 29950
Date:

I agree with you though SomeChick (by the way, good to see you back).

EVERYTHING is out there on the web now. But this is really starting to push the envelope.

What will be next? The secret designs to a new weapon the US is developing?

If I were an undercover agent or informant I'd be extremely nervous about this.

__________________


Super Star of Spice!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 1590
Date:

Well, I can't actually see the website.  It's blocked on my computer.  So that's why I'm rendered speechless - a rariety again.

__________________
I'm spicey!


Chairwoman Of The Board

Status: Offline
Posts: 665
Date:

Then again, the media is the same way. We can't keep a government secret if our lives depended on it (and usually it does.)  The media has to put it out there on the 5 o clock news. There are just some things I'd rather not know.  If it's keeping me safe, fine.  Don't tell me about it. Just do it.


 



__________________
Thank you for being a friend!


Permanent State of Confusion

Status: Offline
Posts: 27006
Date:

As much as it seems to be free speech, the harmful effects outweigh the supposed good. We are supposed to be protecting our police and agents, after all, they are the ones doing their best to protect us from the evil in the world. Say what you will about the saying it is used for defense attorneys, but I believe that this site is nothing but a stopping ground for criminals. They watch who they do business with and where. Unfortunately, there are probably worse fears that can be confirmed, that criminals use this site as a hit list. After any type of undercover agents are exposed, they are no longer good for police work. This ruins careers.


 



__________________

Stop trying to be what you see. Be what you ought to be.



Doesn't Do Windows



Status: Offline
Posts: 25589
Date:


I think the idea of the thing is just wrong.

I have to question how complete their database really is though. I searched "Nebraska" and came up with no results. You can't tell me there are no under cover agents or informants in this state.

I guess I'm saying that I don't think something like this that could undermine the efforts of public safety or law enforcement should be allowed. But, I still wonder if they are really making a difference in the grand scheme of things.




__________________




Grand Poobah

    



Status: Offline
Posts: 36897
Date:

It would be a much better world if everyone just elected me the world policeman.  

__________________
"And like Web, I enjoy throwing JR under the bus.  Problem is, it's usually under the special bus that I ride every day". Ghostdancer 12-18-09


The Mediator

Status: Offline
Posts: 5356
Date:

I don't agree with this website at all. First, if these people are informants, this puts them in danger. I browsed around it a bit, but from all the profiles I saw, maybe one was real. It looks like if there's someone you don't like, you can put them up without any evidence that they really are an agent or informant. So, this puts innocent people in danger as well.

Free speech and all, I don't think the website should be shut down, but if they claim it is for lawyers, a user should have to register to even look at the profiles and provide proof of their credibility.

__________________


2011 Super Bowl Champions!

Status: Offline
Posts: 29950
Date:

WebGuy,

I think the fear is that it will continue to grow, and to be honest, I could therefore be part of the problem.

I originally heard this topic on a local radio talk show late last week. That station reaches tens of thousands in the area. Obviously we reach only 100+ at best right now, but the point is that just by talking about it you're making it better known. With that growth it may well take off and become a real problem.

I guess I feel safe talking about it, because in all honesty are any of our 100 or so listeners that are sitting at work right now likely to be criminals that would take shots at a cop or an informant?

But when it's being talked about on broadcast radio and tv, it WILL spread.

Also, I haven't checked it out thoroughly, but I'm sure on the streets of NY, Miami, LA, etc it's A LOT better known than on the streets of any Nebraska town.

__________________


Doesn't Do Windows



Status: Offline
Posts: 25589
Date:


I completely agree with you JR. It could grow to be a real problem.

Molly, brings up a good point too . . . I hadn't even considered the idea of posting someone on the site just because you don't like them.

I still think it should be shut down. This whole "free speech" thing has gone too far. If something is harmful, it should not be allowed under "free speech".



__________________




The Mediator

Status: Offline
Posts: 5356
Date:

I don't think this site falls under the free speech category. It is endangerment and deformation of character. Especially on those like this one that is obviously false. I can say, "Webguy murdered his postman," and technically, although free speech, it's illegal because it's not true.

__________________


Chairman Of The Board

Status: Offline
Posts: 897
Date:

I think that it could easily be a eye for an eye site.
You told something on me (or just ticked me off) so I or my buddies will post you on the site.

__________________


Super Star of Spice!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 1590
Date:

Ya know if they are going to have sites like this they should make it so only lawyers can access it. 


For example did you know there is an totally other internet that only dr. can access.  And another ex. my bro - is in law school and only law students can enter this site that gives you a background check on people if you have their name and dob. 


So this is probably a bogus site - but like I said I haven't seen it.


I mean if all of us can access it and add to it - c'mon how "official" is it.



__________________
I'm spicey!
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard